This episode traces the true story behind Jacksonville’s so-called 'Devil’s School': its 1917 construction as a progressive, airflow-optimized school; its transformation into Annie Lytle Elementary; and its slow decline after Interstate 95 severed the neighborhood and led to closure in 1960. Condemned by 1971 and battered by two major fires, the building became a canvas for urban legends—cannibal principals, satanic teachers, and boiler-room horrors—all thoroughly debunked by historians and the Annie Lytle Preservation Group. The hosts emphasize how psychological factors, environmental decay, and moral panics (like the 1980s–90s satanic panic) fuel ghost stories, while highlighting the real people—teachers, custodians, preservationists—who shaped and now protect the site. The episode balances respectful historical inquiry with critical media literacy, urging listeners to look beyond sensationalism to honor the building’s authentic legacy.