The paranormal-themed Game Night kicks off with categories like Tulpa Terrors, Big Beasts, Stiffs, and Undead or Alive. The contestants tackle questions about Gamera, gremlins, and the Colossal Titan, with early points going to Primo and Dan. As the game progresses, the competition heats up with questions on Japanese urban legends, Godzilla, and the wendigo. A scoring glitch awards Primo points for an incorrect answer, sparking a debate about the rules. Lechuga shines with a correct answer about Chinese hopping vampires, while Fredo struggles with questions about Bhuta spirits. El Profe takes the lead mid-game, but the final rounds see Dan making a strong comeback. The game concludes with Dan taking the win, El Profe in second, and Fredo finishing with negative points. The crew reflects on the game's difficulty, shares anecdotes from past episodes, and jokes about Fredo's reckless strategy, wrapping up with plans for future themed trivia nights.