The investigation begins with Paul and Krista overcoming technical issues to explore the asylum's layered history, including a room where a nurse died from scalding bathwater and a memorial for children. Paul draws a challenge to determine his location, leading him to the basement and the infamous bathtub. The team recounts the story of Nurse Marie Elizabeth Sturm, who died in 1961, and Paul feels something touch his leg while exploring the hydrotherapy room. Despite poor reception, Paul continues exploring the grounds, noting creepy spots like a corridor and chapel, and decides to stay inside while others investigate the woods. The building's instantly creepy atmosphere, complete with Halloween decorations and a clown prop, adds to the tension. Paul wraps up, thanking donors and announcing Krista will continue the investigation live on BMR.