The discussion traces the Ouija board's origins in Victorian spiritualism and its initial marketing as a harmless parlor game by the Kennard Novelty Company. Its reputation shifted dramatically after the 1973 film 'The Exorcist,' transforming it into a feared supernatural object. The hosts debate the ideomotor effect as a scientific explanation versus paranormal beliefs, sharing personal stories that lean toward the supernatural, such as a board correctly spelling a grandfather's nickname and confirming his death. They also examine modern folklore like the Zozo legend and the figure-eight planchette pattern, amplified by the internet. The chapter concludes with the hosts expressing curiosity about trying a Ouija board themselves, highlighting the enduring fascination and terror it inspires.