scripod.com

When Chicago pawned its parking meters

Planet Money

2025/12/12
Planet Money

Planet Money

2025/12/12
In the midst of a fiscal crisis, Chicago made a bold financial decision that would reshape how residents interacted with one of the most everyday parts of city life: parking. Facing pressure to avoid tax hikes, city leaders turned to an unconventional source of revenue—one that seemed painless at first but would spark outrage for years to come.
Chicago’s 2008 lease of its 36,000 parking meters for $1.16 billion was meant to solve budget woes without raising taxes. Investors, led by Morgan Stanley, calculated the deal using present value models, prioritizing immediate returns. The city council approved it quickly, despite warnings from Alderman Scott Waguespack about long-term costs. Soon after, parking rates soared, meters malfunctioned, and the public grew angry as they paid more for less. Hidden documents revealed flawed projections that underestimated future revenue, funneling profits to private operators early in the 75-year term. The city even had to pay penalties when removing meters, losing control over its own infrastructure. What looked like a financial lifeline became a symbol of shortsighted governance and the risks of privatizing essential urban services.
09:21
09:21
Money now is worth more than money later due to the time value of money.
12:07
12:07
The present value of 75 years of parking meter profits was calculated at $1.16 billion.
20:58
20:58
The city had to pay the parking company when taking meters out of service, costing millions.
26:25
26:25
Aaron estimated the 2008 value of the meters at $2.1 billion, nearly double the sale price.