The game begins with a series of summer food matchups. Listeners choose lemonade over iced tea and hamburgers over hot dogs, while State Fair mini donuts surprise the hosts by earning strong enthusiasm. The conversation then moves to frozen desserts, where Dairy Queen Blizzards dominate the vote. The hosts compare waffle cones, cake cones, and bowls, considering how texture, convenience, and nostalgia shape each preference. They also debate whether ice cream trucks or shops offer the better experience: trucks evoke childhood memories, while shops provide more flavors and opportunities to sample. The final food matchup pits lobster rolls against crab cakes, with lobster rolls taking the win. As the competition ends, Stephen and Glen remain tied for the highest score, leaving the episode without a single champion.