scripod.com

Adam Marblestone — AI is missing something fundamental about the brain

Dwarkesh Podcast

Shownote

Adam Marblestone [https://twitter.com/AdamMarblestone] is CEO of Convergent Research [https://www.convergentresearch.org/]. He’s had a very interesting past life: he was a research scientist at Google Deepmind on their neuroscience team and has worked on everything from brain-computer interfaces to quantum computing to nanotech and even formal mathematics. In this episode, we discuss how the brain learns so much from so little, what the AI field can learn from neuroscience, and the answer to Ilya’s question: how does the genome encode abstract reward functions? Turns out, they’re all the same question. Watch on YouTube [https://youtu.be/_9V_Hbe-N1A]; read the transcript [https://www.dwarkesh.com/p/adam-marblestone]. Sponsors * Gemini 3 Pro [https://gemini.google.com] recently helped me run an experiment to test multi-agent scaling: basically, if you have a fixed budget of compute, what is the optimal way to split it up across agents? Gemini was my colleague throughout the process — honestly, I couldn’t have investigated this question without it. Try Gemini 3 Pro today gemini.google.com [https://gemini.google.com] * Labelbox [https://labelbox.com/dwarkesh] helps you train agents to do economically-valuable, real-world tasks. Labelbox’s network of subject-matter experts ensures you get hyper-realistic RL environments, and their custom tooling lets you generate the highest-quality training data possible from those environments. Learn more at labelbox.com/dwarkesh [https://labelbox.com/dwarkesh] To sponsor a future episode, visit dwarkesh.com/advertise [https://www.dwarkesh.com/advertise]. Timestamps (00:00:00) – The brain’s secret sauce is the reward functions, not the architecture (00:22:20) – Amortized inference and what the genome actually stores (00:42:42) – Model-based vs model-free RL in the brain (00:50:31) – Is biological hardware a limitation or an advantage? (01:03:59) – Why a map of the human brain is important (01:23:28) – What value will automating math have? (01:38:18) – Architecture of the brain Further reading Intro to Brain-Like-AGI Safety [https://www.lesswrong.com/s/HzcM2dkCq7fwXBej8] - Steven Byrnes’s theory of the learning vs steering subsystem; referenced throughout the episode. A Brief History of Intelligence [https://www.abriefhistoryofintelligence.com/book] - Great book by Max Bennett on connections between neuroscience and AI Adam’s blog [https://longitudinal.blog/], and Convergent Research’s blog on essential technologies [https://www.essentialtechnology.blog/]. A Tutorial on Energy-Based Learning [http://yann.lecun.com/exdb/publis/pdf/lecun-06.pdf] by Yann LeCun What Does It Mean to Understand a Neural Network? [https://arxiv.org/abs/1907.06374] - Kording & Lillicrap E11 Bio [https://www.e11.bio/] and their brain connectomics approach Sam Gershman on what dopamine is doing in the brain [https://gershmanlab.com/pubs/GershmanUchida19.pdf] Gwern’s proposal [https://www.reddit.com/r/reinforcementlearning/comments/9pwy2f/wbe_and_drl_a_middle_way_of_imitation_learning/] on training models on the brain’s hidden states Get full access to Dwarkesh Podcast at www.dwarkesh.com/subscribe [https://www.dwarkesh.com/subscribe?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_4]

Highlights

In this deep exploration of neuroscience and artificial intelligence, Adam Marblestone examines the fundamental differences between how human brains and AI systems learn, focusing on the unique mechanisms that give biological intelligence its remarkable efficiency and adaptability.
09:12
The cortex learns to predict the steering subsystem's innate responses to guide learning.
41:36
Social reward functions in the steering subsystem require vision and audio to understand cues for learning
48:01
Human cultural evolution operates like model-free reinforcement learning over generations.
1:01:42
TD learning may be implemented in the brain through dopamine signaling
1:17:31
Gwern proposed using neural activity patterns as an auxiliary prediction task to improve model generalization

Chapters

The brain’s secret sauce is the reward functions, not the architecture
00:00
Amortized inference and what the genome actually stores
22:20
Model-based vs model-free RL in the brain
42:42
Is biological hardware a limitation or an advantage?
50:31
Why a map of the human brain is important
1:03:59
What value will automating math have?
1:23:28
Architecture of the brain
1:38:18

Transcript

Dwarkesh Patel: The big million-dollar question that I have, that I've been trying to get the answer to through all these interviews with AI researchers, how does the brain do it, right? Like, we're throwing way more data at these LLMs, and they still have...