Following an anonymous tip, detectives subpoenaed Adnan's cell phone records, which led them to Jen Pusateri. Jen eventually testified that Jay told her Adnan strangled Hae in a Best Buy parking lot. Jay initially denied involvement but later confessed, leading police to Hae's car. Adnan denies Jay's story, speculating that jealousy or police pressure motivated the lies. The core of the episode examines the significant inconsistencies in Jay's multiple statements, particularly his changing account of where Adnan first showed him Hae's body, shifting from a Best Buy parking lot to Edmondson Avenue. While police noted this lie, they did not press him on it, and Jay's explanation for the change was logically inconsistent.